First Presbyterian Church
Sag Harbor, New York
Contact & Location for First Presbyterian Church
Loading map…
Service Times for First Presbyterian Church
Sunday 10:00 AM
Worship Service
From the church’s website · checked Oct 2026
Plan your visit
Wheelchair accessible
Programs & Ministries at First Presbyterian Church
About First Presbyterian Church
First Presbyterian Church, known as Old Whalers' Church, has served the Sag Harbor community as a national historic landmark since 1844. Located at 44 Union Street, this welcoming congregation opens its doors to all seekers and visitors, whether new to the area or visiting for a day. Under the pastoral leadership of Rev. Nancy Remkus, the church offers Sunday services at 10:00am featuring inspiring music from a historic 1845 pipe organ, soloists, and a bell choir. The church is fully accessible with a ramp and elevator to the sanctuary. Beyond worship, Old Whalers' Church nurtures youth through its Sunday School program and 'Soulful Songs and Stories,' while fostering community through weekly coffee hour and various events throughout the year.
First-Time Visitor Info for First Presbyterian Church
Dress Code: Not specified — please contact the church directly. Service Format: Sunday worship at 10:00am featuring music from a historic 1845 pipe organ with soloists and bell choir performances, followed by coffee hour. Visitor Tips: The church is handicap accessible with a ramp on the left side of the entrance and an elevator to the sanctuary; visit the events calendar or contact page for directions and upcoming gatherings.
History & building
Founded in 1844
The church says it has been welcoming people in Sag Harbor since 1844. It also calls itself the Old Whalers Church.
What their website says
An open door since 1844.
Ministry, leadership and visit details above come from the church’s own website. They can change, so please confirm with the church.
Note: Church information may be outdated. Please verify details with the church directly before visiting.
Take your faith journey deeper
Get personalized biblical guidance in seconds, not days or weeks.
Continue with YouVersionFree for 7 days · uses your YouVersion account · or start free with email
Quick Actions
Churches Near You
Other Churches Nearby
Take your faith journey deeper
Get personalized biblical guidance in seconds, not days or weeks.
Continue with YouVersionFree for 7 days · uses your YouVersion account · or start free with email