First United Methodist Church
New Carlisle, Ohio
Contact & Location for First United Methodist Church
Loading map…
Service Times for First United Methodist Church
Sunday 9:30 AM
Worship Service
From the church’s website · checked Oct 2026
Plan your visit
What to wear
There’s no dress code, no prerequisites, and no expectations
What their website says
There’s no dress code, no prerequisites, and no expectations
Wheelchair accessible
Leadership
Bob Lybarger
Senior Pastor
What their website says
Meet Bob Lybarger Senior Pastor
Programs & Ministries at First United Methodist Church
About First United Methodist Church
New Carlisle First United Methodist Church, located at 220 South Main Street in the heart of downtown New Carlisle, Ohio, is a welcoming community centered on knowing God, growing in Jesus, and showing love in action. The church emphasizes transformation through faith and extends genuine hospitality to people of all ages and backgrounds, whether they are exploring faith for the first time, seeking a fresh start, or searching for spiritual community. With accessible facilities including an elevator, Sunday worship services at 9:30 AM, and Sunday growth groups at 10:45 AM, the church creates space for spiritual renewal and authentic connection. Members engage in various ministries for children, youth, and adults, along with community outreach and mission projects that extend God's love beyond the congregation.
Planning a first visit to First United Methodist Church? Get our free first-time visitor guide.
Care & support
AA
Addiction recovery
What their website says
AA meets in the Church Lounge every Monday at 12:00 noon.
NA
Addiction recovery
What their website says
NA gathers at the church every Sunday at 6:00 p.m.
Serving the community
Bethel Churches United Food Pantry
Food pantry
What their website says
The Food Pantry is located at the FUMC Family Center”},{
Groups & programs
Vacation Bible School
What their website says
Each year we host an exciting Vacation Bible School (VBS)
Building & facilities
Guiding Shepherd Christian School
What their website says
Guiding Shepherd Christian School”}},
Ministry, leadership and visit details above come from the church’s own website. They can change, so please confirm with the church.
Note: Church information may be outdated. Please verify details with the church directly before visiting.
Take your faith journey deeper
Get personalized biblical guidance in seconds, not days or weeks.
Continue with YouVersionFree for 7 days · uses your YouVersion account · or start free with email
Quick Actions
Churches Near You
Other Churches Nearby
Take your faith journey deeper
Get personalized biblical guidance in seconds, not days or weeks.
Continue with YouVersionFree for 7 days · uses your YouVersion account · or start free with email