First United Methodist Church
Newark, New York
Contact & Location for First United Methodist Church
Loading map…
Service Times for First United Methodist Church
Sunday 10:00 AM
Worship
From the church’s website · checked Oct 2026
Plan your visit
Watch online
Services are streamed online
What their website says
Watch "Live" weekly on our Facebook page.
Wheelchair accessible
Leadership
Rev. Garry McCaffery
Pastor
What their website says
Staff: Rev. Garry McCaffery, Pastor
Programs & Ministries at First United Methodist Church
About First United Methodist Church
Newark First United Methodist Church worships in a traditional and blended style on Sunday mornings. The congregation describes its mission as “Seek God; Support each other; Serve the world; to make disciples of Jesus Christ!” Ministries include children’s ministry, youth group, and small groups, with Safe Sanctuaries policies and minimum standards in place for ministries. Emmanuel Outreach Center is a mission of the church, reflecting its emphasis on service beyond the congregation. The church also hosts community events such as a Fall Rummage Sale and a Veterans Tribute Concert.
Planning a first visit to First United Methodist Church? Get our free first-time visitor guide.
Serving the community
Handy Man Ministries
What their website says
work to complete handyman projects for the church, its members or within our community.
Groups & programs
History & building
Founded in 1805
The congregation began in Newark in 1805. The sanctuary was built in 1854, and the church celebrated the 100th anniversary of its building in 2024.
What their website says
the congregation actually coming together for Christ in Newark in 1805.
Ministry, leadership and visit details above come from the church’s own website. They can change, so please confirm with the church.
Note: Church information may be outdated. Please verify details with the church directly before visiting.
Take your faith journey deeper
Get personalized biblical guidance in seconds, not days or weeks.
Continue with YouVersionFree for 7 days · uses your YouVersion account · or start free with email
Quick Actions
Churches Near You
Other Churches Nearby
Take your faith journey deeper
Get personalized biblical guidance in seconds, not days or weeks.
Continue with YouVersionFree for 7 days · uses your YouVersion account · or start free with email